No Arizona Diamondbacks made the Top 10 Hitters or Top 10 Fielders list on MLB Network Radio’s “Inside Pitch” program.
When I was reading USA Today the other day, anarticle by Bob Nightengalestuck out to me. Writing about the Arizona Diamondbacks, Nightengale talked about how “folks outside the Mountain Time Zone” don’t seem to show the D-Backs any love. While it was something I found true at the time, it was reinforced when listening to MLB Network Radio on Sirius XM the last few days.
On Monday’s episode ofInside Pitch, one of the network’s best shows, host Casey Stern and former MLB pitcherBrad Lidgeoutlined their Top 10 Pure Hitters list. As they ran through their respective rankings, I waited and waited to hearPaul Goldschmidt‘s name called.
As you’ve probably gathered from this article’s title, it never came.
.@CaseySternand Brad Lidge's top ten pure hitters in#MLB. Let the debate begin.pic.twitter.com/OVZ7o3q2tJ
— MLB Network Radio on SiriusXM (@MLBNetworkRadio)August 13, 2018
Instead,Christian Yelichmade both of their lists andDaniel Murphymade Stern’s bunch. Yes, they’re both great lefty sticks with smooth strokes, but you’d be fired as a GM if you took either over Goldie.Andrew Benintendi, with less than 300 career MLB games, also made both lists.
Does Goldschmidt strike out more than you’d like? Yes, but so doesJ.D. Martinez, who made both lists. Goldie, in contrast to J.D., has a great eye at the plate and makes up for his K’s with boat loads of walks. In my mind, getting on base (with at least a decent amount of power) is paramount when it comes to your worth in the batter’s box. Goldie, my friend, isalwayson base.
Of the 11 guys who made appearances on the two hosts’ lists, Goldie’s 2018 OBP is higher than Yelich, Murphy, and Benintendi. Career-wise, though? OnlyMike TroutandJoey Vottorank higher than Goldschmidt.
What about the power? Well, he’s got most of ’em there, too. Below, I’ll list the career OPS (as of August 14th) for the 11 guys who made the lists, plus Goldie.
- Trout (.987)
- Votto (.960)
- Goldschmidt (.930)
- Arenado (.888)
- Martinez (.886)
- Betts (.882)
- Freeman (.878)
- Ramirez (.858)
- Benintendi (.826)
- Altuve (.819)
- Yelich (.814)
- Murphy (.803)
All guys are great, great hitters, but it looks like Stern, who I love because we have the same name, and Lidge had some recency bias.
The following day, Stern, alongside former MLB outfielderMatt Diaz, did the same list with fielders.
.@MattE_Diazand@CaseyStern's top ten defenders in#MLB. Let the debate begin.pic.twitter.com/7kbqPKXkEr
— MLB Network Radio on SiriusXM (@MLBNetworkRadio)August 14, 2018
And while the case isn’t as strong because he’s still getting better, D-Backs’ shortstopNick Ahmedcould have easily been included on the list. Of the three shortstops that made the cut —Andrelton Simmons,Francisco Lindor, andJose Iglesias— Ahmed currently has the highest fielding percentage,total zone runs, and the least errors,per Baseball Reference. Then,according to FanGraphs, Ahmed is tied with Simmons for the most defensive runs saved.
With these kind of lists, it’s always splitting hairs. However, it would be nice to see the D-Backs gets a little more love nationally.
Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations
